Ida Strouth Murder – What Happened

According to Brayboy, on June 27, 1996, Patterson invited Brayboy to the home of Patterson’s mother, Theresa Patterson.
Pursuant to this invitation, Brayboy and his father, William Hunter, went to Theresa’s home on June 27.   Brayboy and Hunter socialized at Theresa’s home for a while, and then Brayboy, Hunter, and Patterson left together.
At Patterson’s request, Brayboy followed Patterson into the basement, where Brayboy sat on the steps and watched while Patterson murdered Ida and Jacob Strouth and Jeremiah Sponsel.
During the murders, Patterson told Ida that she could not keep his baby from him.   Following the murders, Patterson briefly attempted to clean up some of the blood, using a sock placed over his hand.
Despite the details of the murder not having been made public, Brayboy testified in great detail as to the instruments used in the murders, the locations and types of wounds inflicted on the victims, and the particular order in which the wounds occurred.
Brayboy’s testimony was in accord with reports of the medical examiner and various investigators.

Patterson had voiced frustration over not being able to locate Sarah and their young daughter at a number of different times. He struck Ida many times and threatened her with a gun when she refused to answer. Ida eventually relented.

Police found all three victims in the basement of the townhome.   The time of death was estimated at between midnight and 1:00 a.m. on June 28, 1996.

The cause of death of each victim was complex homicidal violence.   The victims’ injuries included knife wounds, blunt force injuries to the face, head wounds caused by a hammer, and strangulation.   None of the gruesome details of the murders were made public until the trial.

At the crime scene, police found several impressions consistent with a bloody, gloved hand. Police also found two sets of footprints in the basement.

One set of footprints was from an unknown source. The other set of footprints matched a pair of shoes later seized from Patterson’s truck;  these footprints were also consistent with an imprint on Ida’s face.   None of Patterson’s or Brayboy’s fingerprints were found in the townhome.

Several people, including Sarah, immediately told police that Patterson might have committed the murders.   Police arrested Patterson on the evening of June 28.

At the time of his arrest, Patterson had a small spot of blood on his ear. There was such a minute amount of DNA in the blood that no definite identification of the blood source could be made.

However, tests showed the blood to be a mixture of two or more persons’ blood, and neither Patterson nor Jeremiah could be ruled out as possible sources.

Minneapolis: Where Is Sarah Strouth Now? Ida Strouth Murder - Age Daughter  And Husband 2022